Carmit Archibald, M.D.

I'm genuinely so confused by the negative reviews. Like... how?! Dr. Archibald is the most wonderful doctor and her staff is beyond lovely. I've been seeing her for 5+ years during which time she operated on a fibroid of mine and initiated pregnancy care for my two daughters (ultimately referred out as she no longer delivers babies). Her bedside manner can't be matched. I now travel to her from the suburbs because I love her that much.

I used to be Dr. Archibald patient for a few years until her new practice was not accepting my insurance. Dr. Archibald was the epitome of professionalism, kindness, caring, empathy, and so humane. I will always remember Dr. Archibald with much affection and respect. One of the best physicians I ever encountered.

Dr Archibald has been my ob/gyn for many years. She did a complicated fibroid surgery that left me in very good shape. I find her very approachable warm & lovely; I have always been able to discuss anything w her and appreciate her care very much.

Avoid. I saw this doctor a few years ago for a difficult procedure. I researched ahead of time hoping to find a compassionate and competent doctor but instead found someone condescending and dismissive. She forced an IUD on me that I clearly didn't want and made me feel like I had to get it or else I would be irresponsible. I asked questions about how it would affect my hormones, etc which she seemed to take offense to. The pain getting the IUD was excruciating and was the worst pain I ever experienced which she dismissed as well (getting the iud would be "just a pinch"). I had constant pain for 6 months after. I also got the HPV vaccine here and she said I was "adulting" by getting it. I think I was 30 years old at the time. So condescending. The entire experience seeing her was honestly traumatizing. She is just terrible, don't go here.

Dr. Archibald delivered my baby 14+ years ago and she continues to be my OB. She is patient and comfortable to talk to. She asks the questions I don't think about asking about myself. I live in NJ and it's definitely worth the trip to NYC to continue seeing her.